Hindustani and Carnatic instruments
(This text has been kindly contributed by Tammo Heikens)
Not only is there a difference in Hindustani and Carnatic music, but also in the instruments that are used by either. Typical Hindustani instruments are the plucked string instruments like the ‘been’ (Rudra veena) sitar, surbahar, sarod and bowed instruments like sarangi, taus, dilruba and esraj. Another type of stringed instrument is the santoor, which uses sticks to play the strings. For wind instruments bansuri and shenai are probably the most common. Prominent Hindustani percussion instruments are the pakhawaj, dholak, kanjira and last but not least the omnipresent tabla. Carnatic string instrument include the Saraswati veena and mandolin. Wind instruments are the murali, venu and nadaswaram, but also the saxophone. Prominent in Carnatic percussion are the mridangam and the ghattam (claypot) Some instruments that are used in both Hindustani and Carnatic are interestingly from western origin, like the violin, the harmonium and several variations of guitars. Also tanpura is used in both styles of music albeit with a different construction. Hindustani stringed instruments often use a gourd (pumpkin) as a soundbox, whereas in Carnatic music similar instruments (e.g. tanpura) are made of solid wood. The harmonium is a small type of hand pumped organ, that was introduced by French missionaries to India and became so widespread that it is now by many considered to be an Indian instrument (which it is not obviously). It became so popular that it would be difficult to find a house in India without a harmonium and has largely taken over the traditional role of the sarangi as an accompanying instrument for vocalists. Many purists however still consider harmoniums unfit for Indian music, because it cannot produce slides from one note to another (‘meend’)
The source of many of the Hindustani instruments can be traced back to Persian instruments that where introduced by Persian court musicians during the Moghul period. Examples are the sitar, which is derived from the sehtar and the santoor which also has a much more ancient counterpart in Persian music. The same holds true for the nature of Hindustani music and explains largely why the Carnatic music is so different from Hindustani. The Carnatic music can be considered a more pure version of the original Indian music of old. Hindustani music on the other hand was the hybrid outcome of the merging of the cultures of India and Persia.